Skip to main content

Account-based submissions require a verified email and are not anonymous. Anonymous and high-risk channels remain closed. Source safety

REKODI

International justice

The ICC Kenya cases: what happened and what was decided

Published:
Sources checked:
(Nairobi time)
Soma kwa Kiswahili

The International Criminal Court's Kenya situation concerns the violence after the 2007 election, in 2007 and 2008. No ICC case from that situation ended with a verdict on the merits: proceedings were withdrawn, terminated or vacated. This guide explains what each outcome means.

Explanatory article based on public sources. Not a REKODI finding or a court record.

Ruto and Sang: charges vacated in 2016

On 5 April 2016 the Trial Chamber vacated the charges against William Samoei Ruto and Joshua Arap Sang and discharged them. This was not an acquittal on the merits, and it was without prejudice to a possible fresh prosecution in future.

Source: International Criminal Court, The Prosecutor v. William Samoei Ruto and Joshua Arap Sang (case page)

The majority judges gave differing reasons. The ICC's explanatory Q&A says the case was not ended because of witness interference or political meddling, and records that Judge Eboe-Osuji, while accepting that interference and meddling occurred, found no evidence of Mr Ruto's or Mr Sang's personal involvement in it. Judicial discussion of interference is not a ruling on who carried it out.

Sources: International Criminal Court, Ruto and Sang: decision on defence applications for judgments of acquittal (PDF); International Criminal Court, Questions and answers on the Ruto and Sang decision (PDF)

Kenyatta: charges withdrawn, proceedings terminated

The prosecution withdrew the charges against Uhuru Muigai Kenyatta in December 2014. On 13 March 2015 Trial Chamber V(B) terminated the proceedings. There was no verdict on the merits.

Source: International Criminal Court, Kenyatta case: Trial Chamber V(B) terminates proceedings

The Chamber noted that the ICC kept jurisdiction over matters such as interference with evidence, and that the termination did not prevent new charges if supported by evidence.

Source: International Criminal Court, Kenyatta case: Trial Chamber V(B) terminates proceedings

The other Kenya cases, branch by branch

Article 70 cases concern offences against the Court itself, such as corruptly influencing witnesses, and are separate from the post-election violence charges. No Kenya case has produced a conviction on the merits. Pending pre-trial cases are not trials, and the existence of the situation is not a new investigation into current events.

Source: International Criminal Court, Situation in the Republic of Kenya (cases overview)

What the ICC cases are not

Recent reports of abductions and protest deaths in Kenya are not ICC cases. They are handled, if at all, by Kenyan institutions and courts. Nothing in the Kenya situation produced a conviction for post-election violence.

These are public-source research notes in REKODI's historical collection. Each note states what its sources establish and what they do not; a note is not a finding of wrongdoing.

More Insights

Sources